We all love the Jersey Shore – but how many New Jersey residents know all of it? Of course, there’s the shore making its way up and down the Garden State’s Atlantic coast, with its world-famous views and attractions. Then there’s the Delaware Water Gap coast, much less known but full of affordable summer getaways. Then there’s the southern coast, home to rural Cumberland County – and it might just be the best-kept secret in the state. This is a heavy fishing and blue-collar area, and it can be a long drive to get there. That’s why I was so surprised to find the best rural seafood restaurant in NJ, The Red Eyed Crab, hiding in the tiny community of Port Norris. It might just have the best seafood in New Jersey, in a wonderfully out-of-the-way location that’s more than worth the drive.

Port Norris is a small town of just over 1,000, which used to be the hub of New Jersey's oyster-fishing industry. Remnants of this can still be seen today - like this massive pile of oyster shells.
Scientific29/Wikipedia
The heart of the town is The Red Eyed Crab, an old-fashioned seafood shack that feels like it came right out of an old movie.
Sandra Lee/Google Local
Inside, the restaurant has a unique nautical feel. It's not hard to figure out that the highlight here is seafood, and lots of it!
Danielle D/Google Local
The best local catch has been fried up, and can be had as a sandwich or in a basket with fries. All the fried options are excellent.
Sam Neuber/Google Local
However, the real highlight here is crabs - perfectly steamed and served with a flavorful seasoning when the fishing season is in full swing.
Danielle D/Google Local
One of the most popular ways to try the seafood here is in a steampot, with a mix of crabs, shrimp, potatoes, sausage, and corn all cooked together .
Beth Marut/Google Local
It's not all seafood classics, though - The Red Eyed Crab also has some modern twists and regional favorites incorporating the same excellent seafood. You'll also find steak and pork entrees if someone in your party isn't in the mood for seafood.
Mike LaSalle/Google Local
Make sure to take a few minutes to look around the restaurant for the various sculptures and nautical designs circling the restaurant - it's a one-of-a-kind place!
J. R./Google Local

Have you visited this rural seafood restaurant in NJ, hidden in the town of Port Norris? Tell us about your visit to The Red Eyed Crab, and your favorite out-of-the-way destinations, in the comments section. The Red Eyed Crab keeps a low profile online, as is fitting for a humble seafood shack, but you can keep an eye on The Red Eyed Crab Facebook page for the latest specials. If you want to learn more about the rural areas of South Jersey, consider a trip down the Bayshore Heritage Scenic Byway. Make sure to bring all the essentials for the road!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Related Articles

Explore New Jersey

Featured Addresses
The Red Eyed Crab, 977 Main St, Port Norris, NJ 08349, USA