10 Indianapolis Sandwiches You Have To Try Before You Die
×
Courtney Johnston
Author
Is there anything more tasty and versatile than the sandwich? Whether you like hot or cold, fried or freshly made, there’s definitely a sandwich for you in Indy. Here are 10 of the absolute best sandwiches to try out of the many mouthwatering options in the Circle City (and trust me, this was a hard list to make):
This tenderloin actually won best tenderloin in the state a couple years ago. While this Irish pub on Mass Ave offers a variety of delicious Irish inspired sandwiches, we recommend you order this tenderloin at least once. You won't regret it. You'll find it at 575 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204.
Advertisement
This Jewish deli offers mouthwatering sandwiches, but their corned beef and pastrami is notches above its competitors. This overly stuffed, enormous sandwich comes on rye bread and is thick cut. It's everything you could ask for in a sandwich. Try it at 808 S Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46225.
If you love pulled pork and homemade BBQ sauce, you have to try this delicious, tender BBQ sandwich from Squealer's. Their recipes are award-winning for a reason. Check them out at 5515 W 86th St., Indianapolis, IN 46268.
Advertisement
If you're a sandwich enthusiast and up for trying incredible, unique recipes, you have to try Wildwood Market in Fountain Square. With a different sandwich offered daily, you'll be delighted and wowed each time you try one of these works of art. This tiny market gets packed around lunch time, but is well worth the wait! Find it at 1015 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203.
This Scottish-American pub has one of the most unique burgers you've ever seen. This massive burger is well seasoned and pounded into a thin patty and topped with your choice of cheese. It's so thin and large that it will cover your whole plate, so you'll actually need to fold it into fours to fit onto the bun. You can try this unique burger at 339 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46204.
If you love seafood, you'll love the delightful fresh fish sandwiches at Caplinger's. With a variety of fresh options to choose from, you'll find your new favorite fish sandwich here. Try it at 7460 N Shadeland Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46250.
This Italian-style sandwich is packed with deliciousness. Topped with a variety of delicious Italian meats and cheese, fresh and spicy giardiniera, tomato preserves, lettuce, and mayo, you'll fall in love at first bite. Try it at 2503 N Delaware St., Indianapolis, IN 46205.
This eclectic grilled cheese is one you won't find anywhere else. Their famous cranberry walnut grilled geneva and racelette cheese is made with black truffle honey and served with a runny egg on top. Try this delicious cheesy concoction at 534 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203.
If you love a good po' boy, you'll want to check out Papa Roux. This hidden gem offers a variety of delicious po' boy sandwiches, but the fried catfish is one of their top sellers. Try them at 8950 E 10th St., Indianapolis, IN 46219.
This little hole in the wall restaurant serves up Chicago-style Italian beef that will have you smiling all day. The sandwich is slightly spicy with delicious au jus on the side. Try it at 619 Virginia Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46203.
How many of these sandwiches have you tried before? Let us know what your other favorites are! For more great places to eat in Indy, check out this tasty taco trail!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.